PANEL DISCUSSION: WHAT KIND OF JUSTICE DO THOSE MOST AFFECTED BY CLIMATE CHANGE NEED AND PREFER? (ERASMUS+ TEACHING)

On Thursday 12 February, the Centre for Legal and Social Research of the Faculty of Law at the National University of Córdoba (UNC) hosted the research meeting of the “Climate Change and Health” strand, organised by the Climate Ethics and Development Foundation in a hybrid format.

The meeting provided a space for dialogue and exchange with grassroots organisations and community groups, academic institutions and public administration actors working on the environment, health and socio-environmental justice.

The conversation was led by Dr Romina Rekers, coordinator of the Bioethics and Climate Change area of the Climate Ethics and Development Foundation, within the framework of the Erasmus+ Teaching programme, through academic cooperation between the University of Graz (Austria) and the National University of Córdoba. The activity was also supported by the project “A case of co-producing ethical standards for climate and health research with members of grassroots women’s organisations in South America”, funded by the World Health Organization (WHO).

This line of work promotes research into the ethical challenges of the climate crisis in relation to public health, human rights and public policy, including:

- Climate and health adaptation strategies in South America.

- Women’s participation in policies on climate-sensitive diseases.

- The right to health in the context of the climate emergency before international bodies.

This research is supported by the Oxford–Johns Hopkins Global Infectious Disease Ethics Collaborative (GLIDE), funded by the Wellcome Humanities and Social Science Award.

The main aim of the meeting was to open a space for listening and dialogue with local actors, to learn about their perspectives, share experiences and explore strategies for cooperation around four guiding questions:

1. How can mechanisms for effective participation in the development of climate and health public policy be designed?

2. What conceptions of justice are held in the face of the climate crisis?

3. What does a fair and adequate response to the climate emergency mean from the standpoint of lived, local experience?

4. To what extent is it appropriate to interpret climate resistance as an expression of climate justice, and to what extent as an active response to processes of socio-environmental destruction? What ethical and political implications follow from these frameworks?  

One of the cross-cutting points of consensus was that participation cannot be reduced to merely formal or consultative exercises. Several contributions noted that, in many institutional processes, existing participatory mechanisms operate as administrative procedures with no real capacity to influence decision-making.

In this regard, persistent obstacles to meaningful participation were discussed, such as:

- The lack of adequate mechanisms for dissemination and access to information.

- Institutional and territorial inequalities in the capacity to exert influence.

- The limitations of non-binding public hearings.

- Connectivity gaps that reproduce exclusion.

- Tensions between technical, legal and community languages.

The importance of specific institutional capacities to sustain robust participatory processes was also highlighted, including facilitation roles, transdisciplinary moderation and prior information sessions to clarify expectations and scope.

The legitimacy of climate and health policies depends largely on their social roots and their capacity to incorporate local knowledge and community experience.

The participating organisations stressed that the climate crisis plays out in deeply unequal ways across territories, and that adequate responses cannot be devised without considering the specific conditions in which socio-environmental struggles take place.

In particular, discussions emerged around so-called sacrifice zones, where environmental degradation is linked to direct impacts on the health, well-being and rights of communities.

It was emphasised that climate justice is not only a global regulatory framework, but also a process built through community organising, territorial resistance and coordination between social actors, local networks and academic institutions.

Another key theme of the meeting was the tension between the production of international concepts and frameworks —such as the Sustainable Development Goals or certain global adaptation metrics— and the real possibilities of implementing them in local contexts.

Several contributions noted that climate policies often face a persistent gap between technocracy and everyday experience: measurement tools, statistical forms and technological solutions do not always capture the social and cultural complexity of local territories.

In this context, participants discussed the need to democratise climate information, strengthen public communication strategies and prevent environmental governance from being confined to specialist languages that exclude affected communities.

From the health sector, it was stressed that the impacts of climate change on health are already visible in many dimensions, although they remain fragmented or insufficiently integrated into professional training.

Specific examples of environment-related illnesses were shared, and the urgent need for comprehensive approaches linking health, the environment, justice and human rights was underlined.

The value of building sustained educational and community spaces —including popular education initiatives and interdisciplinary networks— to respond more effectively to the emerging challenges of the climate crisis was also highlighted.

The meeting reaffirmed the value of transdisciplinary spaces as essential settings for building guiding ethical principles and strengthening climate and health public policies that are legitimate, inclusive and socially grounded.

In a context of growing socio-environmental complexity, it was stressed that fair responses require not only technical tools, but also robust participatory processes, stronger institutional capacity and active social organisation.

At the Climate Ethics and Development Foundation, we will continue to promote opportunities for dialogue with local organisations and actors, with a view to developing future lines of academic, institutional and community cooperation during 2026.

Participating organisations and institutions

The meeting was attended by a wide range of socio-environmental organisations, academic institutions, public bodies and community networks, including:

- Red Internacional de Promotores ODS (Córdoba)

- Fundación para el Desarrollo de Políticas Sustentables (FUNDEPS)

- Madres de Barrio Ituzaingó Anexo

- Foro Ambiental Córdoba

- Jóvenes por el Clima

- Multisectorial Ambiental Córdoba

- Movimiento Verde Cordobés

- AC Mendiolaza Viva

- V.U.D.A.S. (Vecinas Unidas en Defensa de un Ambiente Sano)

- Cooperativa Apícola y Agropecuaria de Villa de Soto

- Fondo Plurales

- Fundación Adelaida

- Centro Vecinal Alto Alberdi

- Interra

Representatives from different levels of public administration also took part, including:

- Municipality of Villa Carlos Paz (Environment Department)

- Environment Directorate of Salsipuedes

- General Secretariat for the Environment, Circular Economy and Bio-citizenship

- Commune of Villa Ciudad Parque (Environment and Health)

- Bioethics Area of the Córdoba Ministry of Health

On the academic side, members of the following institutions attended:

- National University of Córdoba (UNC)

- Catholic University of Córdoba (UCC)

- National University of Villa María (UNVM)

- Universidad Libre del Ambiente

- University of Graz / Goethe University Frankfurt

- CONICET – National University of Córdoba

The diversity of perspectives greatly enriched the exchange and made it possible to identify common challenges for strengthening climate and health public policy.

The Climate Ethics and Development Foundation thanks all the organisations, institutions and people who took part in this space for dialogue. Their contributions are essential to continue building climate and health agendas that are ethically guided, socially grounded and democratically legitimate.